The Best Dupes for Charlotte Tilbury’s Pillow Talk
It’s hard to find good nude lipstick. Some shades are too pale and make you look like you’re on your deathbed; others are a weird shade of brown that’s hard to match. However, Charlotte Tilbury’s Pillow Talk is the perfect nude that looks just like your lips, but better.
This page contains affiliate links, meaning I get a small commission if you decide to make a purchase through my links, at no cost to you. See the disclaimer page for more information.
Pillow Talk is a warm nude with hints of both mauve and brown. Because of those undertones, it flatters every skin tone and makes your face look livelier and healthier. The lipstick also has special 3D glow pigments, which make your lips look full and lush.
Best Dupes for Charlotte Tilbury’s Pillow Talk
However, Charlotte Tilbury’s Pillow Talk is a bit more expensive than other brands and is often out of stock. Plus, a lot of brands have a similar shade but are just not getting as much hype.
So, we scoured the beauty stores to find the best dupes for Charlotte Tilbury’s Pillow Talk. We didn’t just look for the same color. We also checked how it felt on the lips, how long it lasted, and whether the color would “stay true” to the shade—meaning it didn’t oxidize or look different on the lips than on the tube.
We’re happy to say that we found plenty of options. With this list, you can find your “perfect everyday lipstick” without breaking your beauty budget. So keep on reading if you’d like to find the best Pillow Talk dupe for you!
Maybelline Color Sensational in Almond Rose – Our Top Pick
This Pillow Talk dupe ticks all the boxes: color, comfort, and overall texture. It may not last as long as Pillow Talk, but if you don’t mind reapplying halfway through the day, you get the perfect lipstick color at the perfect price.
Features
- Comes in both Matte and Satin finish
- Creamy texture
- Hydrating formula
What we like about Maybelline Color Sensational in Almond Rose
Pillow Talk is iconic not just because of its color, but how comfortable it feels on the lips. Many dupes can match the shade but can dry out the lips or start flaking after a couple of hours.
However, Maybelline’s hydrating formula moisturizes and softens the lips. The creamy formula also glides on—no tugging at the lips, which usually happens when you use a lip crayon.
What we don’t like about Maybelline Color Sensational in Almond Rose
Maybe because it’s so moisturizing and hydrating, the formula tends to fade quickly. You may also need a lip pencil to prevent it from bleeding or transferring.
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Flatters all skin tones | Fades quickly |
| Hydrating formula | Needs lip pencil to prevent bleeding |
| Glides on |
Maybelline Superstay Crayon in Lead the Way
This is almost an exact dupe. It has the right amount of pink and brown undertones and a very matte finish. The pointed tip also allows precise application.
Features
- Built-in sharpener
- Matte finish
- Lasts for 8 hours
What we like about Maybelline Superstay Crayon in Lead the Way
This is a very affordable lipstick that still has great quality. It’s very pigmented and doesn’t feather on the lips. The pointed tip also makes it very convenient and easy to use: you can get a well-defined lip without a lip brush or lip pencil.
What we don’t like about Maybelline Superstay Crayon in Lead the Way
This lipstick can be drying since it doesn’t have the nourishing ingredients found in Pillow Talk and other luxurious brands. If you have dry lips, you need to moisturize with a balm before application, or the lipstick will flake.
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Affordable | Dries the lips if you don’t use lip balm |
| Precise application | |
| Doesn’t feather | |
| Easy and convenient to use |
L’Oreal Paris Color Riche Beige No. 630
It closely matches the shade of Pillow Talk, with the bonus of being more moisturizing and feels lighter on the lips. It’s a good alternative for people who love or hate the “dry feeling” of wearing matte lipstick.
Features
- Oil-infused formula moisturizes lips
- Part of LÓreal’s special limited-edition Cannes Collection
- Pretty gold and red tube with a marbled finish and a Palm D’Or icon
- Satin finish
What we like about L’Oreal Paris Color Riche Beige No. 630
This lipstick is very, very comfortable. feels very light—almost like a lip balm, but with richer pigments. We also like that the color is buildable. One layer will just enhance your natural lip color, while two or more layers will give you a deeper shade.
What we don’t like about L’Oreal Paris Color Riche Beige No. 630
It has more brown undertones, so it may not flatter people with very light or cool skin tones. Which doesn’t make it the best Pillow talk dupe. And like most satin lipsticks, it does fade after a few hours and tends to smear if you don’t use a lip liner.
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Moisturizing | Doesn’t last long |
| Feels light and comfortable | Can smudge/smear |
| Pretty tube | Not suitable for cool or light skin tones |
Flower Beauty Petal Pout in Spiced Petal
While it’s not as famous as other lipstick brands, Flower Beauty makes really good products. Spiced Petal is one of the most famous shades in their collection (which is why it’s always out of stock). Aside from being a perfect match for Pillow Talk, it has a very nourishing formula.
Features
- Enriched with antioxidants
- Matte finish
- Cruelty-free
What we like about L’Oreal Paris Color Riche Beige No. 630
Petal Pout in Spiced Petal pretty much nails the shade: it’s universally flattering and enhances the natural color of your lips. It also feels comfortable and light, and the antioxidants can help your lips stay healthy and smooth.
What we don’t like about L’Oreal Paris Color Riche Beige No. 630
Since it’s a niche brand, it’s hard to find it in big beauty outlets. It’s faster to order from their website, but they’re often out of stock. You also need a lip liner and lip brush to get a really precise application.
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Affordable | Hard to find |
| Nourishing formula | |
| Shade flatters all skin tones | |
| Cruelty-free |
What to look for when buying a lipstick
While the color is the first thing you notice about lipstick, really good formulas give more than just that.
- Staying power. Look for lipsticks that don’t need frequent application. Satin and cream lipsticks will generally fade faster, but should at least give you 6 to 8 hours of wear.
- Pigmentation. This is how rich and vibrant the color is. This is especially important for natural shades because if there’s not enough pigment you will barely see the lipstick. If you have dark lips, you need even more pigments to get the desired effect.
- Formula. The best lipsticks will have antioxidants, oils, or other ingredients that nourish your lips.
Final Verdict – The Best Pillow Talk Dupe
Maybelline Color Sensational in Almond Rose
The best dupe for Charlotte Tilbury’s Pillow Talk is also the most affordable. Maybelline Color Sensational in Almond Rose has a beautiful color that flatters all skin tones and is the perfect “everyday lipstick” for a natural makeup look. It is also hydrating and lightweight, so you enjoy both comfort and color. You can pick up this amazing dupe from Amazon here.
FAQS
What is matte lipstick?
Matte lipsticks don’t reflect a lot of light, so they have a “flat” effect—as opposed to satin or cream which look fuller and shiny. Pillow Talk is unique because it contains 3D glow pigments, so even if it’s matte your lips still look more luscious and healthy.
What are the pros and cons of matte lipstick?
Since the formula doesn’t have a lot of emollients and creams, matte lipsticks last longer and won’t smudge. However, they can dry out the lips if you don’t properly moisturize. Matte lipsticks may also highlight fine lines on the lips.
Jessica Wheeler
Hi! My name is Jessica Wheeler and I am the Senior Editor at Bringing Beauty. I have been a licensed Esthetician for six years and have recently finished my Bachelor of Arts in English.
